Lankes stated, “Bad libraries build collections, good libraries build services, great libraries build communities.” Libraries are valued as “third places” (Cabello & Butler, 2017) and community hubs (Putnam, 2004; Kyle, 2015; Settle, 2016) as they are well-positioned to serve community needs. However, capacity is a central consideration in program decisions. Drawing on published cases, longitudinal data from the Public Library Survey, and web analysis to summarize modern library programming initiatives, the authors undertook surveys and interviews with librarians to improve understanding of library involvement in placemaking and how geography of libraries shapes placemaking involvement and practices.